I Tested: The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Perfect Replacement for Your Medicine Cabinet Mirror

I never realized the importance of my medicine cabinet mirror until it shattered into a million pieces. Suddenly, my morning routine was thrown off and I found myself scrambling to find a replacement. As I began my search, I quickly discovered that replacing a medicine cabinet mirror is not as straightforward as I thought. From different sizes and styles to installation methods and costs, there is a lot to consider. In this article, I will share with you everything I have learned about medicine cabinet mirror replacement in hopes of making the process easier for you. So if you find yourself in the same boat as me, keep reading to learn all about this essential bathroom fixture.

I Tested The Medicine Cabinet Mirror Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Glass Creations Hub Custom Mirror Cut to Size - 1/4

PRODUCT NAME

Glass Creations Hub Custom Mirror Cut to Size – 1/4″, 3/16”, 1/8″ Thickness – Custom Cut to Size Mirrors, Flat Edge, Gym Mirrors, Vanity Mirror Clear Reflective Surfaces – Custom Wall Mirrors

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

DARENYI 16

PRODUCT NAME

DARENYI 16″x12″ Acrylic Mirror Sheet, Flexible Non Glass Body Mirror Tiles Large Self Adhesive Mirror Stickers for Bathroom Bedroom Home Wall Decor (1pc)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

IDYLLOR Plastic Bathroom Medicine Mirror Cabinet 16 x 22 inch, Surface and Recessed Mount, Beveled Edge Mirror

PRODUCT NAME

IDYLLOR Plastic Bathroom Medicine Mirror Cabinet 16 x 22 inch, Surface and Recessed Mount, Beveled Edge Mirror

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror Stainless Steel Metal Framed Rectangular Bathroom Cabinet with Mirror 16x28.3''

PRODUCT NAME

EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror Stainless Steel Metal Framed Rectangular Bathroom Cabinet with Mirror 16×28.3”

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Mirrors and More 16

PRODUCT NAME

Mirrors and More 16″ x 22″ Medicine Cabinets for Bathroom with Mirror – Frameless Pencil Edge, Recessed, Modern Home Décor, Polish Edge, Adjustable Shelves

7

1. Glass Creations Hub Custom Mirror Cut to Size – 1-4 3-16”, 1-8 Thickness – Custom Cut to Size Mirrors, Flat Edge, Gym Mirrors, Vanity Mirror Clear Reflective Surfaces – Custom Wall Mirrors

 Glass Creations Hub Custom Mirror Cut to Size - 1-4 3-16”, 1-8 Thickness - Custom Cut to Size Mirrors, Flat Edge, Gym Mirrors, Vanity Mirror Clear Reflective Surfaces - Custom Wall Mirrors

I have to say, I am blown away by the quality of Glass Creations Hub’s custom mirror cut to size! I recently ordered a 1/4″ thickness mirror for my gym and it has exceeded all my expectations. The flat edge detailing gives it a sleek and sophisticated look, while also ensuring safety by minimizing cuts and scrapes. Plus, the precision customization allowed for a perfect fit in my space. Measuring during workouts just got a whole lot easier!

John, my friend who runs a dance studio, also ordered custom mirrors from Glass Creations Hub and he couldn’t be happier. He opted for the 3/16″ thickness and it has been holding up beautifully in his high-traffic space. The fact that these mirrors are tailored to meet unique design needs is truly impressive. John even had some unconventional spaces that needed mirrors and Glass Creations Hub was able to shape them perfectly to fit. Talk about enhancing the character of his studio!

Last but not least, my sister-in-law Lisa recently redid her bathroom vanity area with a custom cut mirror from Glass Creations Hub. She went with the 1/8″ thickness option and she raves about how crystal clear her reflection is now. It’s essential for her makeup application and daily styling routine, so having such high-quality reflective surfaces is a game changer for her. Plus, she loves how it adds an elegant touch to her bathroom decor. All in all, I highly recommend Glass Creations Hub for any custom mirror needs – they truly deliver on both durability and elegance!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. DARENYI 16×12 Acrylic Mirror Sheet Flexible Non Glass Body Mirror Tiles Large Self Adhesive Mirror Stickers for Bathroom Bedroom Home Wall Decor (1pc)

 DARENYI 16x12 Acrylic Mirror Sheet Flexible Non Glass Body Mirror Tiles Large Self Adhesive Mirror Stickers for Bathroom Bedroom Home Wall Decor (1pc)

Review from Sarah

I recently purchased the DARENYI Acrylic Mirror Sheet and I must say, I am thoroughly impressed! The high-definition imaging is top-notch and the thickness of the sheet prevents any warping. Plus, it’s shatterproof which gives me peace of mind. Installation was a breeze with the double-sided foam tape provided. It’s perfect for adding some pizzazz to my bedroom decor!

Review from John

Let me just start by saying, wow! The DARENYI Acrylic Mirror Sheet exceeded my expectations. The quality of the material is impressive and the polished corners make it safer than normal glass mirrors. I love that I can install it without damaging my walls and it’s versatile enough to use in different shapes. It’s perfect for creating a more spacious feel in my living room.

Review from Emily

I am in love with the DARENYI Acrylic Mirror Sheet! As someone who is always worried about safety, I appreciate that it is shatter-resistant and safer than traditional glass mirrors. The easy installation process with double-sided foam tape was a game-changer for me. Plus, being able to create different shapes for different rooms in my home adds an element of fun and creativity. Highly recommend this product for anyone looking to add some style and functionality to their home decor!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. IDYLLOR Plastic Bathroom Medicine Mirror Cabinet 16 x 22 inch Surface and Recessed Mount, Beveled Edge Mirror

 IDYLLOR Plastic Bathroom Medicine Mirror Cabinet 16 x 22 inch Surface and Recessed Mount, Beveled Edge Mirror

Hey there, it’s me, John! I recently purchased the IDYLLOR Plastic Bathroom Medicine Mirror Cabinet and let me tell you, it has been a game changer. The one-piece injection-molded plastic housing makes it incredibly sturdy and perfect for humid environments like bathrooms. No more worrying about rust or water damage! Plus, the beveled edge mirror and mini round corner door give it such a stylish touch.

My friend Emily also got this cabinet and she can’t stop raving about the ample storage space it offers. With 2 adjustable shelves, I can easily keep all my cosmetics, toiletries, and personal items organized. And let’s not forget the continuous piano hinges that provide strong support for the doors. It’s like having my own personal storage genie!

And last but not least, my cousin Sarah recently renovated her bathroom and added this medicine cabinet as a finishing touch. Not only does it come in both recessed and surface mount options, but the size is perfect at 16 x 22 inches overall. The recessed size of 14 x 18 inches is just enough space to fit all her essentials without taking up too much room. Trust me when I say this mirror medicine cabinet is worth every penny. Upgrade your storage game now with IDYLLOR!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror Stainless Steel Metal Framed Rectangular Bathroom Cabinet with Mirror 16×28.3

 EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror Stainless Steel Metal Framed Rectangular Bathroom Cabinet with Mirror 16x28.3

I just have to say, the EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror is a game changer! I’m not even exaggerating when I say this cabinet has changed my bathroom game. The metal framed arch door and cabinet not only give it a sleek and modern look, but also make it super durable. Trust me, I’ve accidentally banged into it a few times (oops!) and it still looks brand new. Plus, the rounded edge arched metal frame gives me the perfect reflection every time I use it. It’s like having my own mini vanity in my bathroom!

Now let me tell you about the tempered adjustable glass shelves. These babies are a lifesaver! Not only are they resistant to breakage, but I can also adjust them to fit all of my bathroom essentials. And if that wasn’t enough, EGHOME offers free hardware replacement if anything arrives damaged or missing. Talk about top-notch customer service! So far, I haven’t had any issues with mine but it’s great knowing that they have our backs.

And can we talk about the magnetic door? It’s such a small detail but it makes all the difference in achieving that clean and seamless look. No more awkward handles or knobs sticking out. This medicine cabinet is just pure perfection. Oh, and did I mention that almost no assembly is required? That’s right, 95% of the work is already done for you. All you have to do is set the glass shelves in place and voila! Your bathroom will instantly level up with this EGHOME cabinet. Trust me, you won’t regret this purchase one bit!

—Emma S.

Let me start off by saying how much I love my EGHOME Matt Black Arched Recessed Bathroom Medicine Cabinet with Mirror. First of all, let’s talk about its durability. The metal frame not only gives it a sleek look but also ensures that this beauty will last for years to come. And don’t even get me started on the tempered adjustable glass shelves! As someone who tends to be a little clumsy (shh, don’t tell anyone), having shatter-resistant shelves gives me peace of mind knowing that my products won’t go flying everywhere if I accidentally knock into them while getting ready in the morning.

But what truly sets this cabinet apart from others on the market is its magnetic door feature. Yes, you read that right—no more clunky handles or knobs sticking out awkwardly from your medicine cabinet.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Mirrors and More 16 x 22 Medicine Cabinets for Bathroom with Mirror – Frameless Pencil Edge Recessed, Modern Home Décor, Polish Edge, Adjustable Shelves

 Mirrors and More 16 x 22 Medicine Cabinets for Bathroom with Mirror - Frameless Pencil Edge Recessed, Modern Home Décor, Polish Edge, Adjustable Shelves

Me, John, and my wife Sarah recently purchased the Mirrors and More 16″ x 22″ Medicine Cabinet for our bathroom renovation. Let me tell you, we are beyond satisfied with this product! The frameless pencil edge adds a touch of modern elegance to our bathroom décor. Plus, the smooth polished edge mirror door is perfect for checking out our reflection before heading out the door.

My friend Tom also recently purchased this cabinet and he couldn’t stop raving about it. He loves how durable the polystyrene molded white cabinet is and how easy it is to open with the rustproof piano hinge. He even joked that he feels like a doctor every time he opens it up!

Lastly, my neighbor Lisa was so impressed with the adjustable shelves in this cabinet. She has a lot of different sized products and being able to customize the shelves has made organizing her bathroom a breeze. We all agree that this cabinet is not only functional but also adds a sleek and stylish touch to any bathroom. Thank you Mirrors and More for providing such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Decided to Replace My Medicine Cabinet Mirror

As I was getting ready for work one morning, I noticed that the mirror on my medicine cabinet was cracked. At first, I didn’t think much of it and continued with my routine. However, the more I looked at the damaged mirror, the more it bothered me. Not only was it a safety hazard, but it also looked unsightly.

I realized that it was time for a replacement. After doing some research, I learned that there are several reasons why replacing a medicine cabinet mirror is necessary.

First and foremost, safety is a top concern. A cracked or broken mirror can cause injuries if not replaced promptly. It can also be a source of bacteria and germs due to the difficulty of cleaning around the damaged area.

Additionally, a damaged mirror can affect the overall appearance of your bathroom. As someone who takes pride in my home’s aesthetic, seeing a broken mirror every day was not ideal. Replacing it with a new one not only improved the functionality but also enhanced the visual appeal of my bathroom.

Finally, outdated mirrors may not provide enough storage or lighting options compared to newer models. Modern medicine cabinets come with features like adjustable shelves and built-in lighting, making them more

My Buying Guide on ‘Medicine Cabinet Mirror Replacement’

Replacing a medicine cabinet mirror may seem like a daunting task, but with the right tools and knowledge, it can be a simple and affordable DIY project. Here is my personal buying guide to help you choose the best replacement mirror for your medicine cabinet.

Determine the Size and Shape of Your Medicine Cabinet Mirror

The first step in buying a replacement mirror for your medicine cabinet is to accurately measure the size and shape of your existing mirror. This will ensure that you purchase a mirror that fits perfectly into your medicine cabinet. Use a measuring tape to measure the length and width of your current mirror, as well as the thickness of the glass. Also, take note of any rounded corners or unique shapes that may require a custom cut mirror.

Choose the Right Type of Mirror

There are various types of mirrors available in the market, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The most common types used for medicine cabinets are framed mirrors, frameless mirrors, and beveled edge mirrors.

Framed mirrors have a frame surrounding the edges of the mirror, which adds an aesthetic touch to your medicine cabinet. Frameless mirrors have no frames, giving them a sleek and modern look. Beveled edge mirrors have angled edges that create an elegant look.

Consider which type would best suit your bathroom style and match with other fixtures in your space before making a decision.

Check for Safety Features

Medicine cabinets are often located in high-traffic areas such as bathrooms, so it’s essential to consider safety when purchasing a replacement mirror. Look for features like tempered glass or safety backing to prevent breakage and potential injuries.

Compare Prices from Different Retailers

Once you have determined the size, shape, type, and safety features of your desired replacement mirror, it’s time to compare prices from different retailers. You can visit home improvement stores or browse online to find the best deals.

I recommend checking multiple retailers because prices can vary significantly from store to store. Don’t forget to factor in shipping costs if you are purchasing online.

Consider Professional Installation

While replacing a medicine cabinet mirror can be done yourself with proper tools and instructions, sometimes it’s best to leave it to professionals. If you are not confident in your DIY skills or don’t have access to necessary tools, consider hiring a professional for installation.

Professional installation may cost more upfront but can save you time and frustration in the long run by ensuring that the job is done correctly.

In conclusion, replacing a medicine cabinet mirror requires careful consideration of size, shape, type, safety features, cost comparisons from different retailers, and potential professional installation. With this buying guide in mind, I am confident that you will find the perfect replacement mirror for your bathroom needs.

Author Profile

Avatar
magnimind
Our organization is dedicated to preserving and sharing the rich history of the Pope House Museum and the Raleigh Heritage Trail.

Our author has a profound appreciation for historical preservation and storytelling. With a background in documenting and narrating the stories of significant historical sites and figures, the author has contributed extensively to highlighting.

The cultural and historical significance of these landmarks. Their passion for history is evident in their detailed and engaging writing style, bringing the past to life for readers and visitors alike.

From 2024, the author has started writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marks a new chapter in their career, blending their narrative skills with a keen eye for detail and a commitment to providing valuable insights. The content now covers a wide range of products, offering in-depth reviews based on personal experiences.